🩸 Vitamin K1 and K2: phylloquinone vs menaquinone — which one you need
One vitamin, two different jobs: blood clotting and calcium in bones
Vitamin K is not one substance but a group of fat-soluble compounds. K1 (phylloquinone) is made by plants and is mainly involved in blood clotting. K2 (menaquinone) is produced by bacteria and found in fermented and animal foods; its main job is to activate proteins that direct calcium into bones and keep it out of blood vessels.
They are often confused because labels and tests simply say "vitamin K". But for the body these are different tools: K1 is the bleeding brake, K2 is the calcium dispatcher.
What K1 and K2 are
K1 (phylloquinone) is the form plants use in photosynthesis. In the body it works mainly in the liver, where it helps make clotting factors II, VII, IX and X. Low K1 means blood stops less efficiently.
K2 (menaquinone) is a family of forms. MK-4 is made in tissues from K1 and cleared quickly; MK-7 comes from natto and fermented foods and stays in the blood longer. K2 activates osteocalcin and matrix Gla protein (MGP): the first supports bone mineralisation, the second protects vessels from calcification.
Deficiency symptoms
In adults, vitamin K deficiency is rare: leafy greens usually provide enough, and gut bacteria make some K2. But risk groups exist — newborns, people with liver or biliary disease, fat malabsorption, and those on anticoagulants.
- Easy bruising and bleeding gums.
- Prolonged nosebleeds or bleeding after minor injuries.
- Blood in urine or stool — a red flag that needs a doctor.
- In newborns — risk of haemorrhagic disease (VKDB), which is why vitamin K is given after birth.
Functions
Blood clotting
K1 is needed to activate clotting factors. Without it the liver produces inactive proteins and bleeding is harder to stop.
Bones
K2 activates osteocalcin, a protein that binds calcium in bone. Human data on K2 and bone density are mixed, but mineralisation suffers when K is deficient.
Vessels
MGP prevents calcium deposition in artery walls. K2 is needed for its activation, which is why K2 is discussed together with vitamin D and calcium.
Newborns
The placenta passes little vitamin K, and breast milk contains little. All newborns are therefore recommended a preventive vitamin K dose.
Food sources
K1 means greens and cruciferous vegetables. K2 is found in natto, hard cheese, egg yolks and liver. Fat helps absorption of both.
| Food | Vitamin K | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| Kale | ~800–1,000 µg K1/100 g | Record holder for K1 |
| Spinach | ~480 µg K1/100 g | Better with oil |
| Broccoli | ~100 µg K1/100 g | Some is lost in cooking |
| Natto | ~1,000 µg K2 (MK-7)/100 g | Richest K2 source |
| Hard cheese | ~50–80 µg K2/100 g | MK-7 and MK-4 |
| Egg yolk | ~30 µg K2/100 g | Small amount |
| Liver | K2, variable | Not daily |
Norms
K1 has an adequate intake (AI); K2 has no official RDA. The values below are for preventing deficiency, not therapeutic doses.
| Group | Norm | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| Men 19+ | 120 µg K1/day | AI |
| Women 19+ | 90 µg K1/day | AI |
| Pregnancy/breastfeeding | 90–120 µg/day | As prescribed |
| K2 | 90–120 µg/day | Guide, not RDA |
| Upper limit | Not established | Warfarin changes everything |
Forms and absorption
| Form | What it is | Features |
|---|---|---|
| K1 (phylloquinone) | Plant form | For clotting; less common in supplements |
| MK-4 | Short K2 form | Cleared quickly, often split into several doses |
| MK-7 | Long K2 form | Stays in blood longer, convenient once daily |
K1 and K2 are fat-soluble, so take them with a meal containing fat. MK-7 has a longer half-life than MK-4 and is better suited to daily support.
How to take
- With food containing fat. Otherwise absorption drops.
- MK-7 once daily. Its long half-life means no need to split.
- With vitamin D3. D helps absorb calcium, K2 directs it into bones; a logical pair.
- With warfarin — only after consulting a doctor. Even "safe" K2 can change INR.
Contraindications and risks
- Warfarin and other vitamin K antagonists. Vitamin K weakens their effect.
- History of thrombosis. Do not start without a doctor.
- Pregnancy and children. Normal food amounts are safe; supplements as prescribed.
- Allergy to ingredients. Rare but possible.
How does vitamin K1 differ from vitamin K2?
K1 is mainly for blood clotting; K2 activates proteins that direct calcium into bones and protect vessels. They are different forms with different jobs.
Can vitamin K2 be replaced with vitamin K1?
Not one-to-one. The body can convert some K1 into MK-4, but not enough for full bone and vessel support.
How much vitamin K2 do I need per day?
No official RDA; a guide is 90–120 µg of MK-7 daily. Studies often use 90–180 µg.
Is vitamin K2 dangerous with warfarin?
Yes, vitamin K weakens warfarin. A doctor must approve and monitor INR.
Which foods are highest in vitamin K2?
Natto, hard cheese, egg yolk and liver. Natto is the richest source of MK-7.
Do children need vitamin K2?
Usually food is enough. Newborns receive vitamin K by protocol. Supplements for children only as prescribed.
Can vitamin K2 be taken with vitamin D?
Yes, it is a logical pair: D helps absorb calcium, K2 directs it into bones. With kidney or heart disease, ask a doctor.
Does cooking destroy vitamin K?
K1 is fairly heat-stable, but some leaches into water during boiling. Baking and steaming preserve more.
Is there an upper limit for vitamin K?
No official upper limit is set, but high-dose K2 is poorly studied. With warfarin, INR control matters more than the upper limit.
How is vitamin K deficiency checked?
Usually by clotting tests (PT/INR) and clinical signs. There is no routine K2 test; diet and risk groups guide assessment.
Who especially needs vitamin K2?
People with osteoporosis, high vascular calcification risk, older adults and those taking vitamin D and calcium. Decide with a doctor.
Can K2 be obtained from normal food?
Yes, if natto, cheese, eggs and liver are in the diet. Where natto is unavailable, a supplement may be discussed.